Going Electric: Routes and Charging Determine the Business Case

Volatile diesel prices are prompting many companies to take another look at the cost of running their fleets. But comparing the purchase price of an electric vehicle with the cost of fuel is not enough. Routes, downtime, charging options and vehicle utilisation all help determine whether an electric vehicle makes sense for a particular operation.

Recent developments in Europe show that companies are planning for more than just the vehicles themselves. GEODIS has ordered 110 electric 44-tonne trucks for its European road transport operations. In France, the company plans to provide charging opportunities every 250–500 kilometres along key routes and aims to expand its network to more than 200 charging points by 2030. GEODIS announcement

That detail matters: buying the vehicles does not solve the charging challenge. The location, power and availability of chargers all affect whether a fleet can keep to its daily schedule.

Match the vehicle to the job

UK operator Pall-Ex has put a 28-tonne electric truck into service for urban deliveries. The IVECO S-eWay Rigid has a stated range of up to 400 kilometres and supports high-power charging of up to 350 kW. The company says it will use the truck for city freight, where manoeuvrability and local emissions restrictions can also matter. GREENFLEET report

That does not mean the same vehicle will suit every company. Fleets need to check range, charging time and payload against their own routes and cargo. Regular urban routes that start and end at a depot call for a different charging plan from longer, less predictable journeys.

Charging location affects costs too

Charging at home, at a depot or at a public station can involve different costs and administrative requirements. A new partnership between vaylens and Rightcharge, for example, aims to automate reimbursement for company vehicles charged at home in the UK. This can help companies manage charging costs accurately by vehicle and driver, particularly when vehicles charge both at work and at home.

Opening depot chargers to other hauliers can also improve infrastructure utilisation. UK operator Welch Group has included this approach in its own financial model. The company forecasts substantial savings by 2035, but its estimate is based on its own fleet and future operating assumptions; it should not be treated as a general forecast of savings for other businesses. Welch Group’s model

Where should you start?

Start by collecting data on daily routes, mileage, downtime, loads and return-to-depot patterns. Then model home, depot and public charging separately, alongside financing and maintenance costs. It is also useful to compare several fuel-price scenarios.

The business case for an electric fleet cannot be determined by a single vehicle specification. The key questions are whether a vehicle can do the job and how much it will cost the company to operate over its full service life, including the necessary charging infrastructure.